收到accenture consulting analyst program 同 pwc public sector consulting offer 想問應該點揀



先睇吓間firm+as+a+whole。Worldwide嘅評語同ranking整體都會favourable+to+PwC+consulting,始終consulting/advisory業務較廣泛,用Vault+ranking嚟睇(如上圖)2020年PwC排第8,而Accenture排第11;講開淨睇Public+Sector,原來Accenture排第三,PwC反而第5,其他範疇參見以下兩圖:

Source:+Accenture+-+2020+Vault+Consulting+50+Ranking+Website
不過話說回頭,ranking呢啲嘢好死,反正兩間都係top+tier又差唔遠,加上gradjob又應該暫時睇番香港market同出路,所以我都睇咗好耐唔同人嘅LinkedIn+profiles。當然可以expect嘅係,PwC+Management+Consulting+on+Public+Sector嘅人係好少,如果想知其實係做咩嘅可見下圖:

簡單嚟講,就係幫唔同Public+Sector+organisations去build+the+city,advising+on+public+policies同implement+new+processes+or+tech等,做嘅範疇好似好宏觀但期實反而真係政府政策level;相反Accenture就比較industry-focus,貼近番啲大家認識嘅management+consulting。Accenture係有佢做開嘅industries,可見下圖:
Source:+Accenture+Careers+Website+/+Brochure
Source:+Accenture+Careers+Website+/+Brochure
Accenture嘅programme就係train你做一個management+consulting+generalist,你接到嘅project係唔會限於某一industry(at+least+within+programme...),感覺上作為一個好天真好傻,未熟晒各行各業,一個未定性嘅fresh+grad好似彈性同空間大啲,情況就有啲似大家都想入MT+rotational+programmes咁,有得走位,試過先快定;而PwC就唔洗講,你已經入揀定team。

Source:+LinkedIn
最後講吓career+path。睇番上圖係我唯一搵到比較有指標性嘅profile+reference,如果入PwC條path就會傾向可以入一啲有關Town+planning+/+policy-driven嘅公司,例如MTR或直程入政府;如果係Accenture,睇你自己爭咩job做啦。 Conclusion就係一句廢話,人工其次,反正大家都知某一間總會低少少。要揀就要睇你想入咩sector同exposure,想做policy類就P,想試下先想有tech+training嘅就A。All+the+best+🤞🏻



咁想問呢,我聽accenture既人講佢地好似做好多digital transformation project,通常0.5-2年,我驚會有啲悶。反而pwc public sector consulting好似多啲strategy projects, avg timespan會比較短,係你既認知入面係唔係真啊?


