OnMyGrad Logo

[Sos] 交通銀行 vs 南豐the mills 選擇

#finance
.
28-May-2020
last edit: 01 Mar
我讀非專科ibba 最近收到交通銀行business processing dept offer(應該係做housing mortgage loan同legal reference /documents,詳細唔太清楚,係分行到做)。南豐the mills investment offer (做 startup research,valuation, analysis, for 投資startup)

交銀雖然係細,但有銀行個名。the mills唔出名,但我對startup investment 工作內容有興趣多啲。兩間都唔知intern arrangement 點樣,驚安排好亂,學唔到野。

如果之後想入銀行應該做邊間可以對我cv 更add value,學到多啲野? 

同埋如果交銀做半個月quit,係咪一定比人blacklist,對我之後搵銀行工有冇影響?

thanks so much 




6303 view
9 answers
#1
.
last edit: 17-Jun-2020
a
#2
草子xv
28-May-2020
如果唔係final year 就試多啲唔同嘅嘢啦, the Mills 專投資啲fashion & textile 方向嘅project, 聽落都有趣, 應該會有多啲平日無嘅exposure
銀行相關經驗一定會對banking grad job 有幫助, 但係交行做branch經驗又未去到十分亮麗, 叫做識多少少銀行(分行)運作咁解

至於做唔完quit, 又無乜影響, 要睇下之後有咩跟住做, CV唔好吉咗. 可能交行HR會記得, 有機會小氣😂
#3
Curry
28-May-2020
南豐 London 有incubation Center 
應該都唔太細?
利申好想入 但first round interview 都冇😿
#4
Smallpopo
last edit: 28-May-2020
想問個係summer intern? 南豐intern 已出結果?
#5
Xyz
last edit: 05-Aug-2020
其實the mills都唔差,同埋如果你諗住spring做bank intern,咁我覺得take the mills個offer會好啲。

因為其實遲啲做bank,or even advisory都有機會做返corporate research/valuation/analysis,當然都睇你咩division,但係其實係transferable嘅skillset嚟。
相反,交行可能係多啲人識,但係如果你咁講,感覺上啲skillsets冇咁有value,同埋你之後spring嘅bank intern都有機會接觸到。

純屬淺見😂最緊要都係make個覺得自己啱嘅decision

#6
Yo! Sushi
29-May-2020
做分行不了
last edit: 01-Jun-2020
放心吧,驚The Mills細咪寫南豐囉😂

但樓上講得啱,其他佢UK都出名,有位LSE grad同我分享過吓🧐
.
01-Jun-2020
所以你建議我take邊個offer?因為我都唔ssure
#8
Ringo#403_3351
17-Dec-2020
交銀用中文system 
普遍大行 外資都用英文system 
所以不了
#9
Stephen#73_5494
02 Nov

It depends on your career goals, go to the commercial bank, it's stable, you will have a great work-life balance and medical/loan benefits, the working environment might be not such pushy, but the job might be "boring" as they have a standard system to do all the things, and you are the person who can be replaced by anyone. Therefore, working in an investment role will be more fun and you need to keep learning all the time, every deal is different, sometimes you will have to spend your spare time working/researching the projects, but the career might be better if you deliver a great performance. 


Both of them have good reputation, NF group is quite famous too, so don't worry about the company name, after you have work exp, your next employer will pay more attention to your previous job nature/ job duties you have done, rather than the name